Originally Posted by
noodlers
dave
it rewrites codex rules and adds things. the problem with saying hey lets let you use the formations is then the "tax" such as not being able to have skyfire or also having -1 BS to ground targets are quickly forgotten. while the dogfight phase seems easy enough to do away with, i think theres a lot of information in the rest of the book that can be quickly overlooked or forgotten unless both players are completely familiar with the rules. in addition, there is a certain unfairness to one player who has made their list with these rules in mind and another who is oblivious to it and gets blindsided at the events, good or bad.
brian